Anne - LOL It has been a pretty darn good year! So glad I got to share a debut year with you...
LTMAadison Hmm. Well, LT, they paid me for the essay a while back, both with money and a bunch of contributor's copies. I also signed a contract giving them rights to re-use the essay in other anthologies and on "future merchandise" without further compensation. So, are you saying I shouldn't have signed that? That's entirely possible - but you should know the original anthology wasn't the first appearance of this essay in the world! It came out in a magazine prior to the Chicken Soup. So the "first rights" were long gone...
Anyway, I think it's pretty cool, and I have an agent who vets all my contracts now. Still - I'd do it again, no question. Sorry about your experience. Of course, if they tried to offer you NO money for your work, the answer is no.
Also, I would be extremely curious to know if other soup lines are printing essays on the labels? I would think Chicken Soup would be one of the very few players in that game!